The Undertaker is Warren's father, and the protagonist of the Graveyard Shift scenario. During the Hard Times scenario, he purchases an amulet from the Devil, which is later destroyed, cursing him with bad luck. He eventually leaves Warren and Florence, choosing to wander in search of a cure for the curse. He eventually settles in a small town, where he begins working as an undertaker. The citizens of the town are later slaughtered by cultists. He then assembles a posse to destroy the cult, battling cultists and demons along the way, before finally facing off against his own demonic son in Purgatory.